What are the Differences between a Hydraulic Winch and an Electric One?


A hydraulic winch performs off of the hydraulic system of a vehicle, and in most cases, the power steering pump. The hydraulic winch does not actually require a more powerful battery for it to operate, and in most cases, will pull harder and longer than a similar sized electrical unit. The winch also has the capacity to operate while it is completely submerged in water. Maybe one of its other best attributes is its ability to pull for longer periods of time than an electric winch, without any over-heating.


Another advantage of the hydraulic winch in vehicle-mounted applications, is its outstanding operation in cold climates. With the advantage of being powered by the vehicle’s ample power steering pump, the hydraulic fluid is pre-warmed before entering the winch motor. This warm hydraulic fluid ideally keeps the winch’s motor warm and ready to operate, even in bitter cold weather. So, the warm winch is more able to pull harder than a cold one and produces better results. If you’re in the UK and seeking a renowned, experienced and professional powered winch hire company, look no further.


Battery systems in all vehicles are designed to operate at a high-power output for a short period of time, such as when starting the engine. But with the electric winch this can be disadvantageous, because the motor produces heat and draws huge amounts of power from the battery. As the winch confronts difficult pulling conditions, the motor can start to overheat. The electric winch will then lose power and start to damage the winch motor, sometimes even at the outset of the use of such a winch. This obviously results in a weaker and less-effective winch at all times.


The hydraulic winch will seldom be damaged by everyday use and not become too hot to operate if a difficult job presents itself. It is a rare occasion that the engine on the winching vehicle ever be operated at any speed above idle to operate the pull. The vehicle’s power steering pump provides the required power right from idle.


One basic drawback to the hydraulic winch, is that it will only work while the vehicle’s engine is running. Under some circumstances, that can be a hindrance to the winch’s capabilities. Another drawback lies in the fact that a damaged power steering line will not only make the vehicle more troublesome to steer, it will also make the winch practically unworkable.


Some of the other benefits of using a hydraulic winch are that it is likely to last for quite a long while as it is very durable and if given proper maintenance, such as when parts need replacing, a hydraulic winch shall serve you for a lengthier period of time. It has the strength and capacity to operate heavy loads which an electric winch just can’t tackle.  It may be better for electric winches to be used on smaller projects, because of the electric supply, they need to function. Which winch to use? Decides on you and your job! You decide and use only the best out there!

Comments are closed.